Testing Period: May 12th through Jun 4th, 1999
This 3rd IPSec Interoperability Test was performed amongst equipment supporting DES (56-bit) encryption algorithm using automatic (IKE Pre-Shared Key) exchange as the key exchange method. "Re-Keying" was also confirmed in this 3rd IPSec Interoperability test; something which was not tested at the 2nd IPSec Interoperability Test.
| Vendor Name | Product | Version | Manufacturer |
| Nextcom | Firebox II | SMS3.3 | WatchGuard |
| Intel Japan | VPN Gateway Plus | Version 6.60 | Intel |
| DIT KK | PERMIT/Gate 4520 | Version 1.10.028 | TIMESTEP |
| CRC Sogo Kenkyu Sho | |||
| Kanematsu Electronics | Ravlin10 | Version 3.1 | RedCreek |
| Net One Systems | Sidewinder Security Server | Version 4.1 | SecureComputing |
| OneGate (FreeGate) 1000 | Version 1.3 Beta | FreeGate | |
| Net One Systems | Contivity Extranet Switch | Version 2.10.06 | NORTEL |
| NORTEL Networks | |||
| Marubeni Solution | |||
| Marubeni Solution | Raptor Firewall | Version 6.0 | AXENT |
| Trilogy | cIPro-VPN | Version 3.34cc | RADGUARD |
| Toyo Technica | |||
| NTT Software | |||
| MCM Japan | VSU1010 | 2.51b11 | VPNet |
| NTT PC Communications | |||
| NetMarks | |||
| Furukawa Denki Kogyo | Mucho-EV | Version 20.00 | Furukawa Denki Kogyo |
| Sumitomo Shoji | RT140 | Beta Version | YAMAHA |
| CiscoSystems | Cisco1720 | IOS 12.03T | Cisco |
| 3COM Japan | PathBuilder S580 | NBPB500-PE
11.2.0.34 |
3Com |
| Memorex Telex Japan | SafeNet/Soft-PK | Version 2.0.4 | IRE |
| Kawasaki Seitetsu | A2DIS VPN Gateway | 1.9.0 Beta | Kawasaki Seitetsu |
| StarNet | STAR-Gateware | Version 210 | StarNet |
| Nihon Telematic | OCN Business Bank VPN (FortKnox) | Version5.0 | Internet Devices Inc. |
| Internet Device Japan |
IPSEC Analyzer (Participants: 1 Company, 1 Product)
Vendor Name
Product Name
Version
Manufacturer
Matsushita Denko
IKEVIEW Analyzer
Ver1.5
Matsushita Denko
NTT Support Members
| NTT Chokyori Kokusai Ikou Honbu Solution Jigyo Div, System Service Sec. |
Tsuda |
| NTT Chokyori Kokusai Ikou Honbu Solution Jigyo Div, 2nd Sales Sec. |
Kumaki & Miyamoto |
| NTT East Japan Ikou Honbu Hojin Eigyo Div, System Service Sec. |
Fukui, Udzuki |
| NTT East Japan Ikou Honbu Hojin Eigyo Div, 2nd Sales Sec. |
Nagasaki, Chiba |
Each product tested had various different modes and settings, so ample time was taken to test various methods to confirm if products were compatible or not. Also, for this testing, a High Speed Digital line (HSD 128) was used to test conformance with remote routers as well for those products which supported such. As for the network configuration and the IP addresses used for the testing, a table including detailed information has been made available along with the results in the Testing Method and Procedures page.
Each products log and other status information concerning public key exchange were reviewed and confirmed and an IPSec Analyzer IKEVIEW was also used to confirm proper sequencing as well as to trouble shoot problems when key establishment or other problems occurred.
(Detailed information concerning IKEVIEW is listed here. IN JAPANESE)
